CONSTITUTIONAL INTERPRETATION methodologies include:
Aonly literal (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories)
BORIGINALISM (original intent / public meaning); TEXTUALISM (text focus); STRUCTURALISM (overall structure); PURPOSIVISM (purpose-focused); LIVING CONSTITUTIONALISM (evolving meaning); MORAL READING (best reading consistent with values)
Conly originalism (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories)
Donly living constitutionalism (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories) (cf. Constitutional Interpretation Theories)
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: B. ORIGINALISM (original intent / public meaning); TEXTUALISM (text focus); STRUCTURALISM (overall structure); PURPOSIVISM (purpose-focused); LIVING CONSTITUTIONALISM (evolving meaning); MORAL READING (best reading consistent with values)
1. CONSTITUTIONAL INTERPRETATION involves multiple methodologies:
2. (i) ORIGINALISM (Antonin Scalia, Robert Bork) — meaning fixed at adoption; (a) original INTENT of framers; (b) original PUBLIC MEANING (semantic);
3. (ii) TEXTUALISM — focus on text itself; less expansive than purposivism;
4. (iii) STRUCTURALISM (Charles Black) — interpretation from overall constitutional structure;
5. (iv) PURPOSIVISM — interpretation by purpose/goal of provision;
6. (v) LIVING CONSTITUTIONALISM — meaning evolves with social change (David Strauss);
7. (vi) MORAL READING (Ronald Dworkin) — best reading consistent with moral values;
8. (vii) PRAGMATISM (Richard Posner) — pragmatic considerations of consequences;
9. (viii) DEMOCRATIC THEORY-based (John Hart Ely) — protecting democracy;
10. (ix) HISTORICAL — drawing on tradition and history;
11. (x) COMPARATIVE — drawing on other constitutional systems.
12. INDIAN CONSTITUTION: Supreme Court applies a mix — Kesavananda Bharati basic structure (purposive); Maneka Gandhi (purposive); Olga Tellis (purposive expansion); etc.
13. Hence option B is correct.
_Source: Legal Research Methodology + Jurisprudence — Constitutional Interpretation Theories_
Related questions
ETHICS in legal research with HUMAN SUBJECTS require:'LIBERAL FEMINISM' in legal theory (Susan Moller Okin, Martha Nussbaum) advocates:RICHARD POSNER's 'PRAGMATIC JURISPRUDENCE' rejects:'ACCESS TO JUSTICE' as a research theme examines:'NATURAL LAW' versus 'POSITIVE LAW' debate centers on:'CONSTITUTIONALISM' as a research theme examines:'SOCIO-LEGAL STUDIES' in India is associated with:'LEX MERCATORIA' (medieval merchant law) and modern transnational commercial law: