'RATIO DECIDENDI' of a case is:
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: D.
1. RATIO DECIDENDI (Latin: 'reason for deciding') is the RULE OF LAW that the court applied in arriving at its decision.
2. It is the BINDING PART of a precedent under the doctrine of stare decisis.
3. The ratio is the proposition WITHOUT WHICH the decision could not stand.
4. Distinguished from OBITER DICTA (Latin: 'said in passing') — observations by judges on points not necessary to the decision; obiter is PERSUASIVE only, not binding.
5. IDENTIFYING the ratio requires interpretation:
6. (i) The MATERIAL FACTS that the court considered relevant;
7. (ii) The LEGAL PRINCIPLE applied to those facts;
8. (iii) The RESULT.
9. Goodhart's test, Wambaugh's inversion test help identify ratio.
10. Hence option B is correct.
_Source: Legal Research Methodology + Jurisprudence — Ratio decidendi doctrine_
Related questions
ETHICS in legal research with HUMAN SUBJECTS require:'LIBERAL FEMINISM' in legal theory (Susan Moller Okin, Martha Nussbaum) advocates:RICHARD POSNER's 'PRAGMATIC JURISPRUDENCE' rejects:'ACCESS TO JUSTICE' as a research theme examines:'NATURAL LAW' versus 'POSITIVE LAW' debate centers on:'CONSTITUTIONALISM' as a research theme examines:'SOCIO-LEGAL STUDIES' in India is associated with:'LEX MERCATORIA' (medieval merchant law) and modern transnational commercial law: