In Arizona v. United States (2012), the Supreme Court:
AStruck down all four of the challenged provisions of the law
BUpheld the entire statute as a valid exercise of state power
CSent the dispute back to Arizona's own courts to resolve
DStruck three provisions but upheld the status-check provision
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: D. Struck three provisions but upheld the status-check provision
1. Arizona's Senate Bill 1070 of 2010 pursued a strategy of attrition by enforcement, and the federal government sued, arguing it conflicted with federal immigration law.
2. The Court affirmed federal supremacy over immigration and struck down three of the four central provisions: warrantless arrest on probable cause of a deportable offence, criminalising the seeking of work without documentation, and criminalising presence in Arizona without valid papers.
3. It upheld the show me your papers provision, which lets officers check the immigration status of anyone they stop or arrest and suspect of being undocumented.
4. The Court warned that applying that provision through racial profiling could expose the state to civil rights lawsuits.
5. Justice Kennedy grounded federal authority in Congress's enumerated power to establish a uniform Rule of Naturalization
so option A overstates a decision that was deliberately partial.
_Source: OpenStax American Government 3e (CC BY 4.0), Ch 3 "American Federalism", §3.4 Competitive Federalism Today_
Keep practising American Federalism
Browse all American Federalism questions for AP US Government and Politics, or explore more Polity topics.
Related questions
Immigration federalism describes:McCulloch v. Maryland is best known for establishing which doctrine?Which level of government is chiefly responsible for garbage collection, according to the Which type of federal grant places the fewest restrictions on how the recipient governmentThe supremacy clause is found in which article of the Constitution?Which of the following is a concurrent power, exercised by both the federal and state goveThe enumerated powers of Congress are listed in: