Order the steps: judge an analogy
Exercise and reference answers
- Steps
- Identify the two things being compared
- Name the respects in which they genuinely resemble each other
- Name the conclusion the analogy wants you to draw
- Ask whether the resemblance is relevant to that conclusion
- Weigh the differences that would break the comparison
Explanation
Name the resemblance, then ask whether it bears on the conclusion. Source: Logic: Deductive and Inductive, Carveth Read (1898), public domain.