Home › GMAT › verbalreasoning › Critical Reasoning Weaken › A study finds that towns near coal mines have hi…
A study finds that towns near coal mines have higher rates of respiratory illness. Which option, if true, MOST DAMAGES the inference that mining causes the illnesses?
AMany residents work in nearby agricultural sectors
BThese towns are also located in valleys that trap industrial pollution from upstream metal smelters
CCoal dust is a known respiratory irritant
DMining companies have safety programs in place
ERates of cardiovascular illness are similar to the national average
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: B. These towns are also located in valleys that trap industrial pollution from upstream metal smelters
1. Identify what is being asked: this is a **Critical Reasoning Weaken** question.
2. Apply the standard approach for this question type to evaluate each option.
3. The correct answer is **B. These towns are also located in valleys that trap industrial pollution from upstream metal smelters** — it satisfies the conditions of the stem.
_Source: GMAC Official 12 Sample Questions (mba.com)_
Related questions
Sales rep: 'Customers prefer X.' Weakens it most:Add to weaken: 'Vitamin C prevents colds.'A claims 'X causes Y' because both rose. Best counter?Newspaper sales fell 30%. Editor concludes ads must rise. Weaken?A factory cut waste 20%. Profits grew the same year. Therefore the cut caused the profit. A trial production run using a new process showed a 15% cost reduction. Managers concluded