Practice free →
HomeUP Board Class 12physicsDual Nature of Radiation and Matter › Which observation does the CLASSICAL wave theory…

Which observation does the CLASSICAL wave theory of light FAIL to explain for the photoelectric effect?

AThe photocurrent grows linearly with the intensity of the incident light
BPhotoemission below the threshold frequency does not occur, no matter how bright the source
CThe photocurrent saturates at a high enough positive collector voltage
DA negative collector voltage reduces the photocurrent to zero
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: B. Photoemission below the threshold frequency does not occur, no matter how bright the source
1. The classical wave theory says light's energy is continuous and depends only on amplitude (intensity). So a bright-enough source of ANY frequency should eventually deliver enough energy to free an electron. 2. Experiment shows the opposite: BELOW a threshold frequency $\nu_0$, the photocurrent is exactly zero regardless of intensity or exposure time. This is the failure that classical theory cannot reconcile. 3. Einstein resolved it by quantising light into photons of energy $h\nu$: if $h\nu < \phi_0$, no single photon has enough energy to free an electron, so no current. 4. Option A is consistent with both theories (more energy → more emissions). Options C and D are about the SHAPE of the current-voltage curve, which classical theory handles fine. Only B is the genuine classical failure. _Source: NCERT Class 12 Physics Part 2, Ch 11, §11.5 (Photoelectric effect and wave theory of light) — explicitly listed failure, p. 6 ¶2._
Solve this in the app — UP Board Class 12 practice & 24k+ MCQs →
Related questions