The chapter argues that the principle of 'equal treatment for equals' alone is insufficient because:
AIt conflicts with the constitutional guarantee of equal citizenship
BIt cannot reward differences in effort, skill or danger in different jobs
CIt violates the dharma tradition that kings should reward the virtuous
DIt would require absolute equality of income across all professions
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: B. It cannot reward differences in effort, skill or danger in different jobs
§4.1 (Proportionate Justice) says treating everyone identically would fail to reward different effort/skill/risk. A miner or policeman doing dangerous work deserves more than someone doing easier work.
Related questions
Informally, a person who seeks to avoid war is called a dove. What is the opposite?What is pacifism?Post-World War II Europe moved from economic integration to political unification. Which aThe first approach to peace manages competition among sovereign states through which arranWhich post-apartheid country is called a prominent political success story?Which country is named as a military dictatorship that uses force against its own people?Inspired by Gandhi, who fought anti-Black discrimination in the USA in the 1960s?How did Gandhi change the meaning of non-violence in a positive direction?