'Most successful business leaders read at least 30 books a year. Therefore, anyone who reads 30 books a year will become a successful business leader.' What is the BEST critique?
AThe argument is valid
BThe argument confuses a correlation in successful leaders (reading habit) with a SUFFICIENT cause for success; many factors other than reading are needed for business success
CSuccessful leaders do not read
D30 is too high a number
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: B. The argument confuses a correlation in successful leaders (reading habit) with a SUFFICIENT cause for success; many factors other than reading are needed for business success
The argument commits the fallacy of confusing necessary conditions or correlates with sufficient causes. Reading may be correlated with leadership; it does not by itself make a leader. The conclusion overreaches.
Related questions
A man rows downstream at 12 km/h and upstream at 8 km/h. His speed in still water isThe compound ratio of 2:3, 4:5 and 5:6 isIf a + b = 10 and a - b = 4, then a × b equalsParadox: 'The cheaper the energy source, the lower the country's per-capita consumption.'
All policies that promote economic growth promote jobs. Some job-promoting policies are enArticle 368 of the Constitution provides the procedure forArticle 51A (Fundamental Duties) was added by theArticle 32 of the Constitution empowers the Supreme Court to issue which of the following