alleryStart learning →All carrot eaters are quarterbacks; John eats carrots; so John is a quarterback. This argument is?
ASound but not valid
BBoth valid and sound
CNeither valid nor sound
DValid but not sound
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: D. Valid but not sound
The conclusion follows from the premises, but the first premise is false, so the argument is valid yet unsound.
Keep practising Problem Solving
Browse all Problem Solving questions for SSC CGL, or explore more Reasoning topics.
Related questions
All men are mortal and Socrates is a man. What is the valid conclusion?If the alarm rings the guard wakes; the guard did not wake. What follows?All rabbits have fur; some pets are rabbits. What follows?All pens are books; all books are bags. What follows?Which type of syllogism is really inductive, not truly deductive?Some A are B and some B are C. What follows about A and C?Which fallacy occurs when both premises of a syllogism are negative?Which fallacy arises when neither premise covers all of the middle term?