A solid disc and a thin ring, having the same mass and same radius, are released from rest at the top of the same incline. Both roll without slipping. Which reaches the bottom first?
AThe disc
BThe ring
CDepends on the incline angle
DBoth reach simultaneously
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: A. The disc
**Key formula.** $a = \dfrac{g\sin\theta}{1 + I_{\text{cm}}/(MR^2)}$. Whichever body has smaller $I_{\text{cm}}/(MR^2)$ has the larger acceleration.
**Apply.**
- Disc: $I_{\text{cm}} = \dfrac{1}{2}MR^2 \Rightarrow$ ratio $= \dfrac{1}{2}$, $a_{\text{disc}} = \dfrac{g\sin\theta}{1.5} = \dfrac{2}{3}g\sin\theta$.
- Ring: $I_{\text{cm}} = MR^2 \Rightarrow$ ratio $= 1$, $a_{\text{ring}} = \dfrac{g\sin\theta}{2} = \dfrac{1}{2}g\sin\theta$.
The disc has higher acceleration → reaches the bottom first.
**Why option D is wrong.** The ratio of accelerations is independent of $\theta$ — both scale the same way with $\sin\theta$. The ordering never flips.
Related questions
A bicycle wheel of radius $R$ rolls without slipping at linear speed $v$. The angular speeAn ice skater spinning with arms outstretched at $\omega_1$ pulls arms in, halving her momA solid disc of mass $M$, radius $R$, rotating about its centre axis has moment of inertiaA child pushes a door of width $0.8$ m perpendicular to the door at the handle with $20$ NMoment of inertia of an annular disc (inner radius r1, outer r2) about perpendicular axis For a solid cylinder rolling without slipping, the friction force at the contact point:A merry-go-round (I = 1000 kg m²) rotates at 0.5 rad/s. A 50 kg child runs and jumps onto A solid cylinder (I = MR²/2) of mass 2 kg, radius 0.1 m, rolls without slipping at 6 m/s.