Home › CS Executive › jurisprudence › Interpretation of Statutes › What is the modern view on the use of 'marginal …
What is the modern view on the use of 'marginal notes' appended to sections of an Indian statute as an aid to interpretation?
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: A.
1. The ICSI text records: 'In England, the disposition of the Court is to disregard the marginal notes. In our country the Courts have entertained different views.'
2. The **weight of authority is in favour of the view that the marginal note appended to a section cannot be referred to for the purpose of construing the section** — *Balraj Kumar v. Jagatpal Singh, 26 All. 393*; reaffirmed by Patanjali Shastri, J. in *C.I.T. v. Anand Bhai Umar Bhai, A.I.R. 1950 S.C. 134*.
3. *However*, marginal notes **appended to Articles of the Constitution** have been held to constitute part of the Constitution and may furnish *prima facie* clue to meaning (e.g. Article 286).
4. Recent decisions (*Sarbajit Rick Singh v. Union of India, (2008) 2 SCC 417*) permit reference to a marginal note when a section is sought to be interpreted differently.
_Source: ICSI CS Executive — Lesson 3, 'Internal Aids — Marginal Notes', pp. 92-93._
Related questions
Why does the ICSI material insist that a statute be construed 'in its context' rather thanRegarding the use of 'Parliamentary History' as an external aid in India, the position is Strict construction is to be applied to certain classes of statutes, while liberal (benefiWhat is the role of dictionaries as an external aid to statutory interpretation, accordingThe 'statement of objects and reasons' attached to a Bill, according to the ICSI material,The Rule of Harmonious Construction directs that a statute be read as a whole to avoid conThe maxim *Contemporanea Expositio Est Optima Et Fortissima in Lege* is invoked in statutoThe Mischief Rule from *Heydon's Case* may be applied only when certain conditions are met