Home › CS Executive › jurisprudence › Law of Torts › Which of the following correctly distinguishes a…
Which of the following correctly distinguishes a 'servant' from an 'independent contractor' for the purposes of vicarious liability?
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: B.
1. The ICSI text gives the control test: 'A **servant** is a person who is employed by another (the employer) to perform services in connection with the affairs of the employer, and **over whom the employer has control in the performance of these services**.'
2. 'An **independent contractor** is one who works for another but who is **NOT controlled by that other in his conduct in the performance of that work**.'
3. So **'a person is a servant where the employer retains the control of the actual performance of the work'**.
4. An employer is **NOT liable for the torts of an independent contractor** committed in the course of his employment, except in three cases: (i) when employer authorises him to commit a tort, (ii) torts of strict liability, (iii) negligence of independent contractor.
_Source: ICSI CS Executive — Lesson 6, '(d) Employer and Independent Contractor', pp. 141-142._
Related questions
Which of the following correctly distinguishes 'strict liability' from 'absolute liabilityUnder Indian law, the position on the State's liability in tort prior to the Constitution An employer is generally NOT liable for the torts of an independent contractor. However, IWhich Latin maxim, traceable to the law of torts, is the general principle on the role of The tort of 'false imprisonment' consists in:In *Jay Laxmi Salt Works (P) Ltd. v. State of Gujarat, 1994 SCC (4) 1, JT 1994 (3) 492*, tStrict liability under the rule in *Rylands v. Fletcher* requires the defendant to have maThe Crown Proceedings Act, 1947 of England substantially altered the position on the Crown