Practice free →
HomeGRE › Verbal Reasoning › Passage (Thomas Babington Macaulay, "Milton," 18…

Passage (Thomas Babington Macaulay, "Milton," 1825, continued from his argument that poetry declines as civilisation advances): "But it is not thus with music, with painting, or with sculpture. Still less is it thus with poetry. The progress of refinement rarely supplies these arts with better objects of imitation. It may indeed improve the instruments which are necessary to the mechanical operations of the musician, the sculptor, and the painter. But language, the machine of the poet, is best fitted for his purpose in its rudest state. Nations, like individuals, first perceive, and then abstract. They advance from particular images to general terms. Hence the vocabulary of an enlightened society is philosophical, that of a half-civilised people is poetical. This change in the language of men is partly the cause and partly the effect of a corresponding change in the nature of their intellectual operations, of a change by which science gains and poetry loses. Generalisation is necessary to the advancement of knowledge; but particularity is indispensable to the creations of the imagination. In proportion as men know more and think more, they look less at individuals and more at classes. They therefore make better theories and worse poems." Macaulay's claim that advanced thinkers "therefore make better theories and worse poems" rests on a key assumption. Which of the following best identifies it?

ATheoretical work and poetic work draw on **different** mental operations — generalisation suits theory; particularity suits poetry.
BTheoretical work and poetic work draw on the **same** mental operations, so progress in one means progress in the other.
CPoets have always been less intelligent than philosophers.
DThe poems of advanced civilisations are unreadable to ordinary people.
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: A. Theoretical work and poetic work draw on **different** mental operations — generalisation suits theory; particularity suits poetry.
The clause *therefore make better theories and worse poems* is a **conclusion** Macaulay draws from his prior premises: 1. *Generalisation is necessary to the advancement of knowledge.* 2. *But particularity is indispensable to the creations of the imagination.* For the conclusion to follow, the two **operations** (generalising for theory, particularising for poetry) must be **distinct** — otherwise improving one would also improve the other. **A** names that load-bearing assumption. - **B** is the **opposite** assumption — what Macaulay's argument is built to deny. - **C** imports a moral / intellectual ranking absent from the passage. - **D** is a tangential claim about audience. GRE move: identify the unstated assumption an argument needs to be valid.
Solve this in the app — GRE practice & 24k+ MCQs →
Related questions