Home › CA Final › financialreporting › consolidation › A Ltd. and B Ltd. set up C Ltd. to build and ope…
A Ltd. and B Ltd. set up C Ltd. to build and operate a toll road. A Ltd. constructs (2 years) and earns cost + fixed margin. B Ltd. operates (sets tolls, manages, earns residual cash). Under Ind AS 110, who has CONTROL over C Ltd. from inception?
ANeither — control evaluation cannot start until C Ltd. begins operations
BB Ltd. — it has the ability to direct the activities that most significantly affect C's RETURNS (operating decisions including toll-setting and residual cash flow)
CA Ltd. — it has decision rights during the construction phase (2 years)
DJointly — A and B share strategic control of C Ltd.
Answer & Solution
Correct answer: B. B Ltd. — it has the ability to direct the activities that most significantly affect C's RETURNS (operating decisions including toll-setting and residual cash flow)
Para B12 — when different investors have rights to direct different activities at different times, control belongs to the party that directs the activities that most significantly affect RETURNS. A's construction work earns a fixed margin (limited exposure to return variability); B's toll-setting + residual cash flow drives the return. B controls C Ltd. from inception, even though A has decision-making rights during construction. This is the "variable returns" + "power link" test combined.
Related questions
An investor holds 30% of equity AND is also the asset manager of an investment vehicle. ThMr. X (an individual) holds 100% of Company A. Mr. X is not a corporate entity and does noUnder Ind AS 110, PROTECTIVE RIGHTS are:Under Ind AS 110, SUBSTANTIVE RIGHTS confer power if the holder has the PRACTICAL ABILITY A Ltd. is the asset manager of Fund X (a venture capital fund). A holds 10% of Fund X's unFive investors each own 20% of Entity Z and each has one seat on Z's seven-member board. SUnder Ind AS 110, an investor has POWER over an investee through:Under Ind AS 110, an INVESTMENT ENTITY measures most of its subsidiaries at: